I used RTV to seal the WARN manual locking hubs to my hubs as well. The hub still just fell off into my hand once the last screw was removed. Usually the locking hubs require quite a bit of prying to remove. Not this one. Personally, I think moisture was penetrating through the rotating cap on the WARN manual hub lockers. I checked a while back with WARN to see if they offered a rebuild kit or seal for their hubs. They did not. Their solution was to purchase a new set of manual hubs.
I guess if I had really been trail driving my Truck hard and had it submerged in water a lot, I would expect some moisture penetration like this. If I drove him hard I would have been performing more preventive maintenance on him too. That wasn't the case this time. I've been pretty easy on the little fellow for quite a while now.
I totally agree with the OEM parts seeming having more longevity than after market parts. These Moog wheel bearing assemblies are still manufactured in Japan. I'll still use Moog parts, I'm just not going to be running any WARN hubs in the future. While I welded my front diff into the "locked" position, it is now just an open differential so other than the CVs turning constantly and maybe wearing the seals on the carrier a little more, he'll run OK with the factory fixed hubs.
The vibration was greatly reduced when I took him out for a drive, however, I still can feel and hear a little vibration/rumble. I suspect the passenger side is in bad shape as well. I ordered another new Moog hub to install on the passenger side of the truck. If the driver's side was as bad as it was, then I suspect the passenger side is little better.
Still, a couple new hubs (about $165 from Rock auto) and the Tracker will be running as smooth as ever. I still love this little tin can truck. Even with 208K miles on him, (after I replace the other front hub assembly) I'd hop in him and drive him anywhere tomorrow.
I did have a link for replacement splash shields for the front rotors on my old computer. I would have to fire it up again to see if the link is still on it and if those parts are still available.