Have you tried graphing the output of the TPS, the engine doesn't need to be running for this, what you're looking for is to see a smooth change in resistance with no spikes or drop outs. Your new aftermarket TPS sound like they are defective to me, as I am not expecting to see the resistance go up, then down, then up and finally open circuit - I'm expecting low resistance to higher resistance in a fairly linear fashion - the actual values can be determined from the manuals, but are not critical to this discussion, the smooth progression is what I concerned about.
Take fixkick with a pinch of salt and go to Ack's FAQ and download the factory manuals for yourself.
The TPS is not really a factor in mixture setting, it's primary role is so the ECU can detect when the throttle is closed, wide open, and the rate at which it is opening - if you're familiar with carburetors, the rate of opening correlates to the action of the accelerator pump on a carb, and that is the cause of the flat spot or hesitation when it's disconnected.