I'm probably going with the Uniroyal Liberator A/T ($85), but if I feel real cheap, the Goodyear Wrangler ($60). Wal-Mart carries them in-store, and since my wife works there, I get 10% off. You can also order a bucnh of other models vonline and they'll ship for pickup at your local WM at no charge.
Thing is, I'm also gonna be replacing the rear bumper with the dual tube Calmini, so who knows what the deal with fitting the spare is gonna be then.
Still gonna just buy 4 now. After I put the new bumper on, I'll check the fit with the new tire.