I took advantage of the 75% off sale at 4 wheel parts yesterday to get my wheels, and ordered my tires and a set of the staun beadlocks. Wheels and tires will be here next week, but the Stauns are about a month out as they just started making them for 17x12" wheels and nobody has them in the US yet.
I went with 39.5x16.5x17 Pitbull Rockers. I based this decision mainly on Billavista's review on the Pirate4x4 board, but I've found dozens of other people with nothing but positive comments, and not a single complaint.
The wheels are 17x12" (recommended size for my tires) Weld Methods. What can I say...they're Weld wheels. I never thought I'd be running them on an offroad rig, but they were so cheap I couldn't pass them up.