I spent a little time looking at acme...seems not very different from Rocky road's kit. Do you have links comparing the "big block 1.6" to the VW diesel setup, and it seems to me the VW setup will make great torque and be better in the mud and for crawling, but looks like it's gonna cost like 1500 bucks, but if it will not be that much better bang for the buck I would run the gas Kick engine.
Am I on the right path?
I just drove my Weber-carbed 1.6 8-valve 900 + miles to the ZookiMelt pulling a 1200-lb camping trailer at 55-60MPH with moderate success. (I plan to convert to a MY-SIDE side-draft carburetor setup someday soom...)
I blew the 9-year-old clutch 120 miles from the Melt but it made it back home with a new clutch just fine! This was done with a second-generation (higher fifth gear) transmission, 4.625 R&Ps, stock t-case and 30" BFG ATs. At the Melt, what wheeling I did was all trail or sand-related and was way above the performance of a stock unit -which is pretty good in the first place!.
I have no experience with the VW Diesel transplant. Cost has kept me from doing it.
That said, if I WAS going to do it I would choose Acme over Rocky Road in a heartbeat no matter what the cost difference was.
Sorry, Glenn...
Acme has struck me as being the better of the two when it comes to service before and after the sale from the posts of others over the course of seven years.
If you are going Diesel, you might as well do it with someone who is there to help you when you need it.
I hope that this helps!